Start Your Order

Pickup Change
Order Type
ASAP Change
When do you want it?
JOHNNY TOMATOES PIZZA - VENICE

JOHNNY TOMATOES PIZZA - VENICE

Open · 3:00 pm - 7:30 pm | 4260 S TAMIAMI TRL, VENICE | 908.265.0913
ASAP · ready in ~20 min · Change
SPECIALS Appetizers Salads Create Your Own Pizza Specialty Pizza Gluten Free Sandwiches Pasta & Dinners Beverages Desserts Sides Pastosa Pasta Catering

SPECIALS

Try our NEW GLUTEN FREE FLATBREADS FOR HALF PRICE! Don't think these are just for our GF friends, EVERYONE will love them!
TWOS-DAYS PIZZA DEAL
Get two XL 18" Cheese pies for only $29.99 every Tuesday! Pickup only, toppings extra.
$29.99
GF Garlic Broccoli Flatbread
Our crazy good flatbread topped with our garlic cream sauce, chopped broccoli, grated and shredded parmesan cheese, mozzarella, and garlic-infused olive oil.
$8.00
GF Bruschetta Flatbread
You won't believe these are gluten free! Crispy and delicious flatbread topped with pesto (contains nuts), chopped tomatoes, chopped garlic, shaved parmesan, and shredded basil, topeed with a drizzle of olive oil and balsamic glaze.
$8.00

Appetizers

Garlic Knots
Made fresh with chopped garlic, butter, olive oil, and grated parmesan. They're soft, a little crispy on the bottom, and really good!
$5.00+ varies by size
Mozzarella Bread
Our homemade breadsticks topped with fresh garlic, parmesan, and mozzarella. Served with a side of marinara.
$12.00
Johnnys Meatballs
Three of our delicious homemade 100% beef meatballs served with our homemade marinara and whipped ricotta.
$15.00
Crunchy Breaded Wings
Our NEW crunchy breaded wings are a smash! Absolutely delicious with a flavorful breading. Give them a try! If you prefer non-breaded wings, they are in the Gluten-Free section.
$11.00+ varies by size
Mussels Marinara
A full pound of delicious mussels served in our marinara with some fresh garlic added for good measure.
$13.00

Salads

Caprese Salad
Ripe red tomato slices with sliced fresh mozzarella, pesto (contains nuts), fresh basil, olive oil, and balsamic reduction.
$12.00
Chopped Caesar Salad
Fresh romaine lettuce tossed generously with mom's famous creamy caesar dressing, grated romano, shredded parmesan, and crunchy croutons. Add chopped chicken cutlet for $5.00. ***CONTAINS ANCHOVY PASTE.
$13.00
Chopped Italian Salad
Crisp romaine lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, black olives, basil, marinated red onions, mozzarella, and grated romano cheese with our house italian dressing.
$13.00

Create Your Own Pizza

Create Your Own Pizza
Our classic pizza with our signature pizza sauce, mozzarella, and grated romano.
$16.00+ varies by size

Specialty Pizza

Choose the pizza you want, and then choose a size to update the price. Available as classic NY style, Sicilian, and Gluten-free!
Margherita Pizza
Crushed Italian tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, grated parmesan, and olive oil
$18.00+ varies by size
White Pizza
Ricotta, mozzarella, grated parmesan, and our signature fresh garlic cream sauce.
$19.00+ varies by size
Holiday White Pizza
Our white pizza topped with broccoli, spinach, and tomatoes.
$20.00+ varies by size
Vodka Pizza
Our vodka sauce with mozzarella and grated romano cheese. Choose our spicy vodka sauce if you like it hot!
$19.00+ varies by size
Fiamma Rosa Pizza
A crowd-pleasing favorite of spicy vodka sauce with mozzarella, cup pepperoni, and Mike's hot honey with fresh basil.
$22.00+ varies by size
Trenton Tomato Pie
A Jersey classic- pizza sauce, plenty of grated romano, and fresh basil. No mozz here!
$14.00+ varies by size
Lasagna Pizza
Sliced meatballs with ricotta, marinara, fresh basil. and grated romano cheese.
$22.00+ varies by size
Hawaiian Pizza
Our classic pizza topped with pineapple chunks and diced ham.
$20.00+ varies by size
Meat Lovers Pizza
Pepperoni, sausage, bacon, meatball, and ham on our classic cheese pizza.
$24.00+ varies by size
Veggie Lovers Pizza
Our classic cheese pizza topped with onions, peppers, mushrooms, black olives, and blistered cherry tomatoes.
$22.00+ varies by size
The Works Pizza
Our classic cheese with pepperoni, sausage, bacon, peppers, onions, mushrooms, and black olives.
$22.00+ varies by size
Chicken Parm Pizza
Chopped chicken cutlet with marinara, mozzarella, fresh basil, and grated romano.
$20.00+ varies by size
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Our own ranch buffalo sauce topped with shredded chicken thigh meat, mozzarella, and ranch & buffalo drizzle.
$20.00+ varies by size
Barbecue Chicken Pizza
Our classic thin-crust pizza with delicious barbecue sauce, topped with shredded chicken, mozzarella cheese, chopped red onions, and barbecue drizzle.
$20.00+ varies by size
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Chopped chicken cutlet, tomatoes, and bacon on a base of our delicious homemade ranch sauce with ranch drizzle.
$20.00+ varies by size
Jalapeno Popper Pizza
Our famous ranch sauce as a base with a trio of pepperjack, american, and mozzarella cheeses, topped off with bacon, jalapenos, and a ranch drizzle. A little spicy!
$22.00+ varies by size
Calzone
The classic half-moon pizza pocket in a personal size with ricotta and mozzarella. Add additional toppings for $1 each. Served with a side of marinara.
$12.00

Gluten Free

Our 12" gluten-free pizzas feature a delicious cauliflower crust that you'll keep coming back for! All specialty pies have gluten-free ingredients, and we do our best to keep cross-contamination to an absolute minimum, but we cannot guarantee zero risk.
12" Gluten Free Pizza
Our Gluten-Free cauliflower crust is actually delicious! Add toppings as you like.
$14.00
Crispy Baked Wings
Medium buffalo, garlic parmesan, BBQ, or sriracha flavor, Served with bleu cheese or our homemade ranch. Available in 6 or 12 pieces. Gluten-Free.
$12.00+ varies by size
GF Pineapple Ricotta Flatbread
As delicious as it sounds! Our flatbread topped with creamy ricotta and pineapple chunks, finished off with shredded basil, Mike's hot honey, and a balsamic drizzle.
$16.00
GF Barbecue Chicken Pizza
$16.00
GF Buffalo Chicken Pizza
$19.00
GF Fiamma Rosa Pizza
$19.00
GF Hawaiian Pizza
$17.00
GF Holiday White Pizza
$19.00
GF Jalapeno Popper Pizza
$19.00
GF Margherita Pizza
$16.00
GF Trenton Tomato Pie
$13.00
GF Veggie Lovers Pizza
$16.00
GF Vodka Pizza
$15.00
GF White Pizza
$16.00
GF The Works Pizza
$19.00

Sandwiches

Great for sharing! Served on our homemade Portofoglio Bread made from our own freshly-made-daily pizza dough.
Caprese Sandwich
Fresh mozzarella, ripe sliced tomatoes, fresh basil, balsamic drizzle, and pesto (contains nuts).
$15.00
Chicken Parm Sandwich
Baked-to-order chicken cutlet with mozzarella and romano cheese. Choose marinara, vodka, or spicy vodka sauce
$15.00
Meatball Parm Sandwich
Our freshly made in-house meatballs with mozzarella and romano cheese. Choose marinara, vodka, or spicy vodka sauce
$15.00
Roman Garlic Chicken Sandwich
Creamy garlic sauce with melted mozzarella and a garlic parmesan drizzle.
$15.00

Pasta & Dinners

Penne Vodka
Penne pasta in our creamy pink sauce with basil and parmesan cheese. Add chicken cutlet for $5.
$14.00
Baked Ziti
Homemade baked ziti (well, penne actually!) smothered in marinara, ricotta, parmesan, and shredded mozzarella. Includes two garlic rolls on the side.
$14.00
Chicken Parmesan Dinner
Two pieces of breaded chicken with our marinara and mozzarella served atop a generous portion of spaghetti, includes two garlic rolls on the side.
$15.00
Spaghetti and Homemade Meatballs
The classic! Spaghetti in marinara served with two our our legendary homemade meatballs! Also comes with two garlic roills on the side.
$14.00

Beverages

2 Liter Choice
$5.00
20 Oz Choice
$3.00

Desserts

Mini Cannoli
3 mini ricotta cannoli with chocolate chips, dusted with powdered sugar.
$9.00
Mini Chocolate Cannoli
3 mini ricotta cannoli with chocolate chips, enrobed in decadent chocolate, and dusted with powdered sugar.
$11.00
Tiramisu
An individual serving of espresso soaked Savoiardi cookies topped with sweet mascarpone cheese finished with dutch cocoa.
$9.00

Sides

Side Marinara
$.50+ varies by size
Side Ranch
$.50+ varies by size
Side Vodka Sauce
$.50+ varies by size

Pastosa Pasta

Italian specialty food company recognized as the source for New York’s finest fresh-made ravioli, pasta and Italian specialties. They ARE worth the price :) The Cheese Ravioli are legendary!
PASTOSA LARGE CHEESE RAVIOLI FROZEN 12 PACK
$12.00
PASTOSA MEDIUM MEAT RAVIOLI FROZEN 36 CT
$16.00
PASTOSA CAVATELLI FROZEN 1 LB
$8.00
PASTOSA MANICOTTI FROZEN 6 CT
$16.00

Catering

Baked Ziti Tray
$50.00+ varies by size
Caesar Salad
$40.00+ varies by size
Caprese Platter
$40.00+ varies by size
Chicken Parm
$60.00+ varies by size
Chopped Salad
$40.00+ varies by size
Manicotti
$60.00+ varies by size
Pasta Salad
$30.00+ varies by size
Penne Vodka Tray
$50.00+ varies by size
Ravioli
$60.00+ varies by size
Sandwich Tray
$50.00+ varies by size
Sausage Peppers
$60.00+ varies by size
Wings Any Style
$50.00+ varies by size
Checkout · 0 item(s) $0.00
Item added to cart