Start Your Order

Pickup Change
Order Type
ASAP Change
When do you want it?
JOHNNY TOMATOES PIZZA - VENICE
We are not accepting online orders right now, but you're welcome to browse the menu. Please check back again soon.

JOHNNY TOMATOES PIZZA - VENICE

Closed · 11:00 am - 9:00 pm | 4260 S TAMIAMI TRL, VENICE | 941.493.1515
ASAP · ready in ~20 min · Change
FOOTBALL SPECIAL PIZZA OF THE MONTH Appetizers Salads Create Your Own Pizza Specialty Pizza Gluten Free Sandwiches Pasta & Dinners Beverages Desserts Sides Pastosa Pasta

FOOTBALL SPECIAL

Football Special- All Season Long!
$45.00
TWO 18" XL classic cheese pies and 12 breaded wings, any style, plus a 2 Liter soda of your choice. Toppings extra.

PIZZA OF THE MONTH

ROMAN GARLIC CHICKEN PIZZA
$20.00+ varies by size
Our homemade garlic cream sauce, topped with parmesan, mozzarella, sliced chicken cutlet, and finished with a garlic parmesan sauce swirl, and fresh basil.

Appetizers

Crunchy Breaded Wings
$11.00+ varies by size
Our NEW crunchy breaded wings are a smash! Absolutely delicious with a flavorful breading. Give them a try! If you prefer non-breaded wings, they are in the Gluten-Free section.
Garlic Knots
$5.00+ varies by size
Made fresh with chopped garlic, butter, olive oil, and grated parmesan. They're soft, a little crispy on the bottom, and really good!
Mozzarella Bread
$12.00
Our homemade breadsticks topped with fresh garlic, parmesan, and mozzarella. Served with a side of marinara.
Johnnys Meatballs Classic Style
$15.00
Three of our delicious homemade 100% beef meatballs served with our homemade marinara and whipped ricotta.
Johnnys Meatballs Parm Style
$15.00
Three of our delicious homemade 100% beef meatballs served with our homemade marinara, grated mozzarella, and parmesan.
Mussels Marinara
$13.00
A full pound of delicious mussels served in our marinara with some fresh garlic added for good measure.

Salads

Caprese Salad
$12.00
Ripe red tomato slices with sliced fresh mozzarella, pesto (contains nuts), fresh basil, olive oil, and balsamic reduction.
Chopped Caesar Salad
$13.00
Fresh romaine lettuce tossed generously with mom's famous creamy caesar dressing, grated romano, shredded parmesan, and crunchy croutons. Add chopped chicken cutlet for $5.00. ***CONTAINS ANCHOVY PASTE.
Chopped Italian Salad
$13.00
Crisp romaine lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, black olives, basil, marinated red onions, mozzarella, and grated romano cheese with our house italian dressing.

Create Your Own Pizza

Create Your Own Pizza
$16.00+ varies by size
Our classic pizza with our signature pizza sauce, mozzarella, and grated romano.
Johnny's Sicilian Pizza
$22.00
A square 16" large pizza with a thick and soft crust with a slightly crispy bottom, mozzarella, and romano cheese.

Specialty Pizza

Choose the pizza you want, and then choose a size to update the price. Available as classic NY style, Sicilian, and Gluten-free!
Margherita Pizza
$18.00+ varies by size
Crushed Italian tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, grated parmesan, and olive oil
White Pizza
$19.00+ varies by size
Ricotta, mozzarella, grated parmesan, and our signature fresh garlic cream sauce.
Holiday White Pizza
$20.00+ varies by size
Our white pizza topped with broccoli, spinach, and tomatoes.
Vodka Pizza
$19.00+ varies by size
Our vodka sauce with mozzarella and grated romano cheese. Choose our spicy vodka sauce if you like it hot!
Fiamma Rosa Pizza
$22.00+ varies by size
A crowd-pleasing favorite of spicy vodka sauce with mozzarella, cup pepperoni, and Mike's hot honey with fresh basil.
Trenton Tomato Pie
$14.00+ varies by size
A Jersey classic- pizza sauce, plenty of grated romano, and fresh basil. No mozz here!
Hawaiian Pizza
$20.00+ varies by size
Our classic pizza topped with pineapple chunks and diced ham.
Meat Lovers Pizza
$24.00+ varies by size
Pepperoni, sausage, bacon, meatball, and ham on our classic cheese pizza.
Veggie Lovers Pizza
$22.00+ varies by size
Our classic cheese pizza topped with onions, peppers, mushrooms, black olives, and blistered cherry tomatoes.
The Works Pizza
$22.00+ varies by size
Our classic cheese with pepperoni, sausage, bacon, peppers, onions, mushrooms, and black olives.
Chicken Parm Pizza
$20.00+ varies by size
Chopped chicken cutlet with marinara, mozzarella, fresh basil, and grated romano.
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
$20.00+ varies by size
Our own ranch buffalo sauce topped with shredded chicken thigh meat, mozzarella, and ranch & buffalo drizzle.
Barbecue Chicken Pizza
$20.00+ varies by size
Our classic thin-crust pizza with delicious barbecue sauce, topped with shredded chicken, mozzarella cheese, chopped red onions, and barbecue drizzle.
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
$20.00+ varies by size
Chopped chicken cutlet, tomatoes, and bacon on a base of our delicious homemade ranch sauce with ranch drizzle.
Jalapeno Popper Pizza
$22.00+ varies by size
Our famous ranch sauce as a base with a trio of pepperjack, american, and mozzarella cheeses, topped off with bacon, jalapenos, and a ranch drizzle. A little spicy!
Calzone
$12.00
The classic half-moon pizza pocket in a personal size with ricotta and mozzarella. Add additional toppings for $1 each. Served with a side of marinara.

Gluten Free

Our 12" gluten-free pizzas feature a delicious cauliflower crust that you'll keep coming back for! All specialty pies have gluten-free ingredients, and we do our best to keep cross-contamination to an absolute minimum, but we cannot guarantee zero risk.
12" Gluten Free Pizza
$14.00
Our Gluten-Free cauliflower crust is actually delicious! Add toppings as you like.
Crispy Baked Wings
$12.00+ varies by size
Medium buffalo, garlic parmesan, BBQ, or sriracha flavor, Served with bleu cheese or our homemade ranch. Available in 6 or 12 pieces. Gluten-Free.
GF Bruschetta Flatbread
$18.00
You won't believe these are gluten free! Crispy and delicious flatbread topped with pesto (contains nuts), chopped tomatoes, chopped garlic, shaved parmesan, and shredded basil, topeed with a drizzle of olive oil and balsamic glaze.
GF Garlic Broccoli Flatbread
$15.00
Our crazy good flatbread topped with our garlic cream sauce, chopped broccoli, grated and shredded parmesan cheese, mozzarella, and garlic-infused olive oil.
GF Pineapple Ricotta Flatbread
$15.00
As delicious as it sounds! Our flatbread topped with creamy ricotta and pineapple chunks, finished off with shredded basil, Mike's hot honey, and a balsamic drizzle.
GF Barbecue Chicken Pizza
$19.00
GF Buffalo Chicken Pizza
$19.00
GF Fiamma Rosa Pizza
$19.00
GF Hawaiian Pizza
$17.00
GF Holiday White Pizza
$19.00
GF Jalapeno Popper Pizza
$19.00
GF Margherita Pizza
$16.00
GF Trenton Tomato Pie
$13.00
GF Veggie Lovers Pizza
$16.00
GF Vodka Pizza
$15.00
GF White Pizza
$16.00
GF The Works Pizza
$19.00

Sandwiches

Great for sharing! Served on our homemade Portofoglio Bread made from our own freshly-made-daily pizza dough.
Caprese Sandwich
$15.00
Fresh mozzarella, ripe sliced tomatoes, fresh basil, balsamic drizzle, and pesto (contains nuts).
Chicken Parm Sandwich
$15.00
Baked-to-order chicken cutlet with mozzarella and romano cheese. Choose marinara, vodka, or spicy vodka sauce
Meatball Parm Sandwich
$15.00
Our freshly made in-house meatballs with mozzarella and romano cheese. Choose marinara, vodka, or spicy vodka sauce
Roman Garlic Chicken Sandwich
$15.00
Creamy garlic sauce with melted mozzarella and a garlic parmesan drizzle.

Pasta & Dinners

Penne Vodka
$14.00
Penne pasta in our creamy pink sauce with basil and parmesan cheese. Add chicken cutlet for $5.
Baked Ziti
$14.00
Homemade baked ziti (well, penne actually!) smothered in marinara, ricotta, parmesan, and shredded mozzarella. Includes two garlic rolls on the side.
Chicken Parmesan Dinner
$15.00
Two pieces of breaded chicken with our marinara and mozzarella served atop a generous portion of spaghetti, includes two garlic rolls on the side.
Spaghetti and Homemade Meatballs
$14.00
The classic! Spaghetti in marinara served with two of our legendary homemade meatballs! Also comes with two garlic roills on the side.

Beverages

2 Liter Choice
$5.00
20 Oz Choice
$3.00

Desserts

Mini Cannoli
$9.00
3 mini ricotta cannoli with chocolate chips, dusted with powdered sugar.

Sides

Side Salad
$5.00
Side Marinara
$0.50+ varies by size
Side Ranch
$0.50+ varies by size
Side Vodka Sauce
$0.50+ varies by size
Side Mike's Hot Honey (2oz)
$1.00

Pastosa Pasta

Italian specialty food company recognized as the source for New York’s finest fresh-made ravioli, pasta and Italian specialties. They ARE worth the price :) The Cheese Ravioli are legendary!
PASTOSA LARGE CHEESE RAVIOLI FROZEN 12 PACK
$12.00
PASTOSA MEDIUM MEAT RAVIOLI FROZEN 36 CT
$16.00
PASTOSA CAVATELLI FROZEN 1 LB
$8.00
PASTOSA MANICOTTI FROZEN 6 CT
$16.00
Checkout · 0 item(s) $0.00
✓ Item added to cart